The afternoon sun streamed through their apartment's tall windows, painting golden rectangles across mahogany furniture that still felt too expensive to touch.

Ember lounged in the reading chair with one of Ash's philosophy books, absently scratching behind Spark's horns while the salamander dozed contentedly in her lap. Her left arm—the one the hydra had severed three days ago—turned pages with perfect functionality, as if it had never been reduced to monster food.

"Pass the chocolate," Pyra called from the kitchen, where she was conducting what could charitably be called 'experimental baking' and more accurately described as 'seeing how many different ways flour could catch fire.'

"You've had enough chocolate," Cinder replied without looking up from her correspondence. She'd been writing letters to various contacts throughout Amaranth's social circles, gathering intelligence on the political currents that swirled around noble sponsorship arrangements.

"There's no such thing as enough chocolate," Kindle protested, emerging from her room with damp hair and wearing one of their new silk robes. "Besides, Ember died horribly three days ago. We're still in the grief-eating phase."

"I'm right here," Ember pointed out.

"You're back from being right there," Ash corrected, not looking up from her own book. "There's a meaningful distinction."

"Philosophical hairsplitting," Ember said, though she was smiling. The familiar rhythm of their banter felt like coming home after a long journey, even when the journey had been through death and back.

"All hairsplitting is philosophical," Ash replied. "That's what makes it hairsplitting instead of analysis."

"What is it when she's just being pedantic?"

"Pedagogy."

"Pedantry. Pedagogy is teaching."

"I was teaching you what the words are."

Kindle and Pyra collapsed into laughter, and Ember set the book aside with a long-suffering expression. "Don't listen to them, Spark. When you need food, come find me."

The elemental salamander looked up at Ember with a contented blink, then went back to sleep.

Ash took her customary seat on the couch, folding her legs beneath her while balancing a cup of tea in the other hand. The two of them were content to read quietly while Kindle's laughter drifted over from the dining room table, where she'd decided to help Cinder work on her letters.

Their domestic routine had settled into comfortable patterns over the past few days. The trauma of Ember's explosive finale at the bog had faded into just another shared experience, no more significant than a particularly challenging mission or an evening of excessive shopping.

Death, for them, was a temporary inconvenience rather than a permanent loss.

The resurrection process had become almost mundane through repetition. Ember had woken in their shared mental space, chatted with her sister-selves about the hydra fight and Marcus's dramatic act of abandonment, and then let herself be brought back into existence after they performed the usual ritual.

The whole process took less than a day and felt more like recovering from a bad hangover than returning from the grave.

Kindle looked up from the letter she was helping Cinder write. "Has anyone seen my destiny crystals? I thought I left them on the table, but now they're missing."

"Check under the couch," Cinder said. "Spark likes to collect shiny objects when he thinks we're not paying attention."

"My crystals aren't toys for him to hoard," Kindle protested, though she was already kneeling beside the furniture to peer underneath. "They're important magical implements for cosmic guidance and fortune enhancement."

"They're overpriced quartz with minor illumination enchantments," Ash said from her reading chair, where she was absorbed in a philosophy text that had survived Spark's literary appetite through strategic placement on high shelves. "And they've never glowed once since you purchased them."

"That's because significant events haven't approached yet," Kindle replied with the confidence of someone whose faith in her purchases remained unshaken by empirical evidence. "When they do glow, we'll be prepared."

"When they glow," Cinder said, "it'll probably be because Spark learned to breathe fire on them."

The salamander chose that moment to demonstrate his developing breath control by exhaling a small puff of flame that singed the brush in Ember's hand. She examined the charred bristles with resignation rather than surprise.

"Third brush this month," she announced. "We need to find brushes made from fire-resistant materials, or train him to control his enthusiasm during grooming sessions."

"Fire-resistant grooming supplies," Pyra mused, emerging from the kitchen with what appeared to be successfully prepared sandwiches. "Add that to our growing list of specialized expenses that normal pet owners never consider."

"Normal pet owners," Ash observed, "don't adopt creatures capable of accidentally incinerating their living spaces during moments of excitement."

"Speaking of Spark's expenses," Cinder said, folding her letter and sealing it with wax that she melted with a casual gesture, "Henrik delivered this month's compliance fees yesterday. They've increased again."

"How much?" Ember asked, though her tone suggested she already expected bad news.

"Fifteen percent," Cinder replied. "Magistrate Cawel's office has reclassified Spark as a 'developing magical creature with enhanced growth patterns,' which apparently requires additional oversight."

"Enhanced growth patterns," Kindle repeated, finding her crystals under the couch exactly where Cinder had predicted. "He's just growing up. All young creatures grow."

"Most young creatures don't grow at rates that suggest they'll reach the size of small buildings within a year," Ash pointed out without looking up from her book. "Spark's development timeline exceeds normal parameters for his species by considerable margins."

"He's special," Pyra said with protective affection, offering the salamander a piece of bread crust that disappeared in a quick snap of tiny jaws. "Special creatures require special accommodations."

"Special accommodations that cost special amounts of money," Ember added, though she continued brushing Spark's scales with obvious care. "Money we're earning through our delightful sponsorship arrangement."

The sponsorship remained a source of persistent tension despite the luxury it provided. House Brightblade covered their expenses and provided financial security, but at the cost of autonomy they hadn't fully appreciated until it was gone. Their schedules, their social obligations, their very identities had become assets to be managed rather than lives to be lived.

"That reminds me," Kindle said, interrupting her careful inspection of the crystals she'd just recovered, "how are we going to explain Ember's mysterious return from certain death?"

"The same way we've explained everything so far," Cinder replied. "We ignore it and hope nobody asks."

"I feel like this one's harder to ignore than, say, when Ash blew herself up in the mines a while back."

"To be fair," Ash said, not looking up from her book, "that was less an actual death than it was an unexpected ejection from my mortal coil. Technically, I was just immaterial until we restored myself to a corporeal state."

"That's my point," Kindle said. "We could explain away one or two of our deaths as freakish occurrences, but Ember's back from the hydra mission is going to require something a bit more creative."

"Less creative," Cinder corrected her. "We'd do better sticking to our previous excuses rather than trying to create new ones. Keeping our story simple makes it less likely that the Magisterium will investigate, and that's to everyone's benefit. A genuine immortal would be far too attractive a prize for even their more ethical members to ignore."

Ember sighed. "I'd rather not become an experiment if I can avoid it. Being dissected by the Magisterium doesn't strike me as particularly fun."

"You'd be back in a day," Pyra offered, though the lack of enthusiasm was telling.

"A day full of uncomfortable invasions and violations. No thank you."

"As lovely as this conversation is," Ash interrupted, finally closing her book and setting it aside, "we should talk about the mechanics of our resurrection capabilities. It's time we understood our limitations."

Ember grimaced. "Are we doing this now?"

"We need to," Ash replied, her neutral expression giving nothing away. "Better that we discuss and prepare now, than risk discovering our limitations in an emergency."

"But it's our recovery time!" Kindle protested, and Pyra joined her in groaning. It was hardly the first time one of them had brought the subject up, but that didn't make it a more welcome conversation.

There was a moment of expectant silence before Cinder sighed, folded her letters, and looked up from her work. "She has a point. We can't keep avoiding this discussion forever."

Ember folded her arms, setting aside her charred brush. "Fine. Where do we start?"

"Start with the most glaring question first," Cinder suggested. "What happens when one of us dies while the rest of us are trapped or incapacitated?"

This tale has been unlawfully obtained from Royal Road. If you discover it on Amazon, kindly report it.

Pyra shrugged. "We've never tried to resurrect one of us without the rest of us present. Would it even work?"

"It should, in theory," Ash answered, though she shifted with the discomfort that always showed when she discussed her less academic experiences. "The resurrection seems to draw from our shared essence rather than requiring all five consciousnesses to be present simultaneously."

"Seems to," Ember repeated. "That's not exactly reassuring when we're talking about permanent death scenarios."

"Nothing about our situation is exactly reassuring," Cinder pointed out, setting down her pen and giving the conversation her full attention. "We're operating on assumptions based on limited data points."

Pyra flopped into the chair beside Ember, causing Spark to chirp in mild protest at the sudden movement. "So what do we actually know? I mean, really know, not just guess?"

"That our rebirth rituals appear to work exactly as we've predicted so far," Ash replied, "that our consciousness appears to exist independently until reunited with our shared essence, and that any injuries we sustained in life are regenerated at the time of our return."

"That's it?" Pyra asked. "That's all we know?"

"We know that Nyx wanted us to suffer," Kindle added quietly, her usual brightness dimmed by the weight of the topic. "The whole point was punishment, wasn't it? Making us unable to bear being alone, even with ourselves."

"But that doesn't explain the resurrection aspect," Ember said. "Being trapped as five people forever is punishment enough. Why add the ability to come back from death?"

Cinder leaned back in her chair, staring at the ceiling as if answers might be written there. "Maybe it wasn't intentional. Maybe the resurrection is a side effect of whatever she did to fracture us."

"Or maybe," Pyra said, warming to a theory, "it's part of the torture. Think about it—we can die, but we can't escape. We're stuck in this curse forever because death doesn't stick."

"That's cheerful," Kindle muttered.

"It's possible," Ash agreed, though her tone was less enthusiastic. "Eternal recurrence as punishment. The curse ensures we remain trapped in our fractured state indefinitely."

"But why five?" Ember asked. "Why not three, or seven, or any other number? There has to be a reason she chose to split us into exactly five pieces."

Spark chose that moment to demonstrate his developing intelligence by climbing from Ember's lap to the arm of her chair, then stretching to sniff at Kindle's recovered crystals. The salamander's tail curled around the chair's upholstery while he investigated whether destiny enhancement crystals might be edible.

"Spark, no," Kindle said automatically, though she was still absorbed in their conversation. "Those aren't food."

"Five elements?" Pyra suggested, watching the salamander with half her attention. "You know, classical magical theory. Earth, air, fire, water, spirit."

"We're all fire-aligned," Cinder pointed out. "That theory doesn't work."

"Five aspects of personality," Ash mused. "In some psychological frameworks, human identity consists of multiple independent components that normally integrate into a cohesive whole."

"You mean like how I'm the impulsive one, Cinder's the tactical one, you're the analytical one?" Kindle asked.

"We're all impulsive," Ember said with a smile. "Some of us are just better at pretending otherwise."

"The point stands," Ash continued. "Perhaps Nyx's curse didn't create new personalities so much as separate existing ones. She took the different aspects of Abigail's identity and forced them into independent existence."

"So we're not really five people," Pyra said slowly. "We're one person who's been... unraveled?"

"That's one way to conceptualize it," Ash agreed. "Though the philosophical implications of personal identity versus shared consciousness become complex rather quickly."

Cinder had been listening with growing thoughtfulness. "If that's true, it explains why we can resurrect each other. We're not actually dying—we're just temporarily losing access to one aspect of our shared self."

"Like losing a limb," Kindle said. "It hurts, and you can't function properly, but the limb can be reattached if you know how."

"Deeply unpleasant analogy," Ember observed, unconsciously flexing the arm the hydra had severed. "But possibly accurate."

"It would also explain why maintaining fewer than five selves creates increasing pressure and pain," Ash added. "A fractured identity naturally seeks to restore itself to completeness."

Pyra frowned. "So... if we die all together at the same time, we can't resurrect ourselves. Because there's nobody alive to do the resurrection."

"That is a logical consequence of the model," Ash agreed reluctantly. "It does suggest that we should have contingencies for minimizing simultaneous deaths."

They sat in contemplative silence, each processing the implications of their theories. Spark had apparently decided the crystals weren't food after all, and was now exploring the possibility that Ash's bookmark might be edible instead.

"There's another question," Kindle said eventually. "Why didn't the curse work the way Nyx intended?"

"What do you mean?" Pyra asked.

"She said we took our gifts lightly, right? That we'd learn how difficult it was to be alone, even with ourselves. But we're not alone. We found each other. We work together. We've made this curse into something that makes us stronger, not weaker."

"Stockholm syndrome," Cinder suggested with dark humor. "We've learned to love our prison."

"Or," Ember said thoughtfully, "we've learned that identity isn't as fixed as most people think. Maybe Nyx underestimated how adaptable human consciousness could be."

"Maybe she underestimated Abigail specifically," Ash added. "Our original self was already someone who thrived on challenge and unconventional solutions. Splitting her into five pieces just gave her more angles to approach problems from."

"So we're not victims of the curse," Pyra said with growing excitement. "We're people who turned a curse into an advantage."

"Don't get carried away," Cinder warned. "This is all speculation, remember? We still don't know if there are other limitations we haven't discovered yet."

"But we're not helpless," Kindle insisted. "We've figured out how to work within the constraints. We've built a life that works despite the restrictions."

"A life that works within the restrictions," Ember corrected gently. "There's a difference."

"Is there?" Kindle asked. "I mean, everyone has constraints. Everyone has limitations they have to work around. Ours are just more obvious than most people's."

"Most people's limitations don't include 'must remain fractured into five separate bodies or suffer unbearable agony,'" Ash pointed out.

"Most people's limitations include 'will age and die naturally within a standard human lifespan,'" Ember countered. "Our constraints might be more dramatic, but they're not necessarily worse."

"Do we actually even age now?" Pyra asked with genuine curiosity. "We might be stuck at twenty-two forever, which... has some definite upsides."

"We age in mind if not body," Cinder reminded her. "But I suspect the curse's physical regeneration will ensure we remain roughly consistent over time."

"That's an interesting question, actually," Ash mused. "If we have children, how might their bodies deal with any complications?"

Ember made a face. "Let's worry about hypothetical children later. I'm having trouble adjusting to just the one unexpected pet."

"So where does that leave us?" Kindle asked. "If we're not victims or prisoners, what are we?"

"We're sisters," Pyra replied firmly. "We're family."

"We're more than sisters," Cinder said, leaning forward in her chair. "Siblings can leave or go their separate ways. We're bound to each other more deeply than that, but being family is still the core of it."

Ember met Cinder's eyes with a grateful expression, and Spark chose that moment to climb up her chair and settle himself in her lap again, his curiosity apparently sated by this exploration of their crystals and bookmark.

"We are," Ember agreed, affectionately stroking Spark's scales.

"Do we even want to reverse the curse?" Kindle asked quietly.

The question stopped all conversation. They looked at each other, five identical sets of golden eyes evaluating what was reflected back at them.

"I don't know," Ember said eventually. "I don't know if I want to stop being me to become someone else, even if that someone else is supposedly our original self."

"We don't know that reversing the curse would erase us," Ash pointed out. "The mechanisms involved could theoretically allow for integration rather than replacement."

"Integration," Cinder repeated. "Like putting together a puzzle to see the complete picture."

"Or like mixing different colors of paint until you get mud," Pyra said pessimistically.

"We're assuming reversal is even possible," Ember said. "For all we know, the changes are permanent. We could be looking for a solution to a problem that doesn't have one."

"Would that be so bad?" Kindle asked. "If we're stuck this way forever, but we make it work?"

"It would mean never knowing what we were supposed to be," Ash replied. "Never understanding our original purpose or potential."

"Maybe our original purpose was to become who we are now," Pyra suggested. "Maybe this is what we were supposed to be all along, and the curse was just the mechanism that got us here."

"That's either profoundly optimistic or deeply disturbing," Cinder observed.

"Why not both?" Kindle asked with a return of her usual brightness.

They lapsed into contemplative silence again, each following their own threads of speculation. The afternoon light had shifted, painting their sitting room in warmer tones that made their luxury furnishings look less like borrowed finery and more like an actual home.

"You know what bothers me most?" Ember said finally. "Not knowing if Nyx is still out there. Not knowing if this curse has other effects we haven't discovered yet. Not knowing if someone else might try to exploit or control our abilities."

"Someone like the Magisterium," Ash said grimly. "Or other noble houses who might see us as useful assets."

"Or other adventurers who might see us as unfair competition," Cinder added.

"Or people who might try to capture and study us to understand how resurrection works," Pyra finished.

"Well," Kindle said with determined cheerfulness, "at least we're worrying about these things together. Whatever happens, whatever we discover about ourselves, we'll face it as a team."

"As a family," Ember corrected.

"As five parts of something larger than any of us individually," Ash concluded.

Spark chirped his agreement, though whether he understood the conversation or was simply responding to their emotional state was unclear. The salamander's simple contentment provided a counterpoint to their complex philosophical struggles—sometimes happiness was just being warm, well-fed, and surrounded by people who cared about you.

Maybe that was enough. Maybe understanding the exact mechanics of their existence mattered less than figuring out how to live with purpose and joy despite the constraints they faced.

Maybe Nyx's curse had backfired not because they'd found loopholes in its structure, but because they'd found something she hadn't anticipated: the ability to build meaning from uncertainty and strength from interdependence.

Or maybe they were overthinking things, as usual.

"So," Pyra said, breaking the philosophical mood with characteristic abruptness, "who wants to help me figure out why my latest batch of biscuits turned purple?"

"Purple biscuits sound interesting," Kindle said, already rising from her chair. "What did you put in them?"

"The usual ingredients, plus some of those berries Henrik brought from the market."

"Those weren't berries," Ash said with alarm. "Those were crystallized alchemical reagents for magical research."

"Oh," Pyra said cheerfully. "That explains the purple. And the sparks."

"The sparks?" Ember asked with growing concern.

"Just little ones. Very pretty, actually."

"Pyra," Cinder said with the patience of someone who'd had this conversation before, "please tell me you didn't eat any of the purple biscuits."

"Just one. Maybe two. They tasted surprisingly good, considering."

"Considering what?"

"Considering they were mildly electrified."

The philosophical discussion about their curse and identity immediately took second place to the more pressing concern of whether Pyra had accidentally poisoned herself with experimental baking.

Some problems, apparently, were more urgent than existential questions about the nature of fractured consciousness and magical resurrection.

Even if those problems involved purple, sparking biscuits made with crystallized alchemical reagents.

If you find any errors ( broken links, non-standard content, etc.. ), Please let us know < report chapter > so we can fix it as soon as possible.